So the goal of
this post is to point the way to clear discussions of some important debates. The
post now is just a brief outline and placeholder. I will add to it as I run
across various sources (sorry this page is quite messy still - slowly sorting it out/growing it).
- Methodenstreit
- Nomothetic - Idiographic debate
- Reductionism
- "Scientism"
- Determinism
Controversy & Personal Debates (Some of these are in
other fields, but have implications for the philosophy of the social
sciences).
- Dawkins - Gould
- Dawkins - Wilson
- Gould's mismeasures (Morton's Skulls)
- The Hoxby-Rothstein debate
- Ron Martin - Paul Krugman, ("Economic Geography" or "Geographic Economics")
- Hartshorne-Schaefer debate
- The Tierney Affair
- The McCloskey & Ziliak - Hoover & Siegler debate (significance testing in economics/social science)
- Wilson - Lewontin/Gould/Rose (sociobiology)
The Hoxby-Rothstein debate
Novel Way to Assess School Competition Stirs Academic Row: To Do So, Harvard Economist Counts Streams in Cities; A Princetonian Takes Issue (Wall Street Journal)
The McCloskey & Ziliak - Hoover & Siegler debate (significance testing in economics/social science)
The Cult of Statistical Significance. Stephen T. Ziliak and Deirdre N. McCloskey Link
Sound and fury: McCloskey and significance testing in economics. Kevin D. Hoover and Mark V. Siegler Link
"Geographical Economics"
Martin, Ron and Peter Sunley. 1996.Paul Krugman’s Geographical Economics and Its Implications for Regional Development Theory: A Critical Assessment. Economic Geography, 72: 259-292. Link
Martin, Ron.1999. The ‘New Economic Geography’: Challenge or Irrelevance? Transactions Institute of British Geographers 24:387-391. JSTOR
Sociobiology
Defenders of the Truth: The Sociobiology Debate. Oxford UP, 2000. Ullica Segerstråle Amazon "Look Inside" and Reviews
Defenders of the Truth: The Sociobiology Debate. Oxford UP, 2000. Ullica Segerstråle Amazon "Look Inside" and Reviews
Dawkins vs. Gould: Survival of the Fittest. Kim Sterelny. Wikipedia summary
The Tierney Affair
Jungle Fever: Did two
U.S. scientists start a genocidal epidemic in the Amazon, or was The
New Yorker duped? By
John Tooby|Posted Wednesday, Oct. 25, 2000. Slate.com Link
Gregor, T. A., & Gross, D. R. (2004). Guilt by
association: the culture of accusation and the American Anthropological
Association’s investigation of Darkness in El Dorado. AmericanAnthropologist,
106(4), 687–698. Link
Dreger, Alice. 2011. Darkness’s Descent on
the American Anthropological Association: A Cautionary Tale. Human
Nature, 22: 225–246. Link
Statement on the Publication of Alice Dreger’s Investigation, Darkness’s Descent on the American Anthropological Association: A Cautionary Tale. Jane B. Lancaster & Raymond Hames. Human Nature, 2011. Link
Statement on the Publication of Alice Dreger’s Investigation, Darkness’s Descent on the American Anthropological Association: A Cautionary Tale. Jane B. Lancaster & Raymond Hames. Human Nature, 2011. Link
---------
Gould’s mismeasures
Gould's skulls: Is bias inevitable in science?
25 July 2011 by David DeGusta and Jason E. Lewis
http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg21128225.900-goulds-skulls-is-bias-inevitable-in-science.html?full=true
Scientists Measure the Accuracy of a Racism Claim, Nicholas Wade, June 13, 2011
Study Debunks Stephen Jay Gould's Claim of Racism on Morton
Lewis JE, DeGusta D, Meyer MR, Monge JM, Mann AE, et al.
(2011) The Mismeasure of Science: Stephen Jay Gould versus Samuel George Morton
on Skulls and Bias. PLoS Biol 9(6): e1001071. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.1001071
Published: June 7, 2011
Like the "Post Autistic" movement in Economics and at about the same time and for the same reasons there was the "Perestroika" movement in Political Science
Cohn, Jonathan. 1999. “Irrational Exuberance: When Did
Political Science Forget About Politics?” The New Republic, October 25, pp. 25-31. Link
“Perestroika” Lost: Why the Latest “Reform” Movement in Political Science. Should Fail. Stephen Bennett 2002. Link
Why Political Scientists Aren’t Public Intellectuals. 2002. PS: Political Science & Politics. Andrew Stark Link
Monroe, Kristen Renwick, ed. 2005. Perestroika! The Raucous
Rebellion in Political Science. New Haven: Yale University Press.
No comments:
Post a Comment